home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=91TT1540>
- <title>
- July 15, 1991: Africa:Tough Terms for a Divorce
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1991
- July 15, 1991 Misleading Labels
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- WORLD, Page 34
- HORN OF AFRICA
- Tough Terms for a Divorce
- </hdr><body>
- <p>Ethiopia's new rulers promise Eritrea the right to secede, but on
- the ground, the pledge is illusory and the reality is far more
- complex
- </p>
- <p>By Marguerite Michaels/Asmara
- </p>
- <p> The requisite niceties aside, it was not the friendliest
- audience that Issaias Afewerki faced as he addressed his
- partners in Ethiopia's new power elite last week. Many of the
- others oppose his plan for Eritrean independence, preferring to
- keep the coastal province firmly within Ethiopia. Issaias had
- a message for them. "Forget history," he told the conference in
- Addis Ababa. "Men make history, and we have made an independent
- Eritrea."
- </p>
- <p> For the moment, his fellow leaders were willing to go
- along. Under a charter adopted by the 81 delegates representing
- 24 different groups, the Eritreans, as well as any of
- Ethiopia's dozens of other nationalities, will have the right
- to self-determination and even secession. The delegates agreed
- that in two years Eritreans would vote on whether to break away
- from Ethiopia. Those who oppose the province's departure are
- plainly hoping that by then independence will have lost its
- allure. Within that time, they anticipate, the Eritrean
- leadership will have failed to create a workable state.
- </p>
- <p> That may be wishful thinking. Ever since 1890, when Italy
- officially colonized the province, Eritreans have considered
- themselves more advanced than Ethiopians. Eritrean rebels began
- fighting for independence in 1961 and since then have done an
- impressive job of providing health care, education and other
- services to rural areas under their control. Ethiopia's dilemma,
- however, is acute: without Eritrea, the nation of 53 million has
- no access to the sea.
- </p>
- <p> Much can happen in two years. In pursuing its separatist
- aims, the Eritrean People's Liberation Front, which Issaias
- heads, must not antagonize the newly installed government in
- Addis Ababa, which replaced Mengistu Haile Mariam, the dictator
- who was deposed in May. Nor can the front afford to alienate
- the international community on which it depends for famine
- relief and economic aid.
- </p>
- <p> Beyond that, the E.P.L.F. must convert itself from a rebel
- army to a civilian government that can resuscitate a region
- devastated by 30 years of war, a land where fields are barren
- and industries are still. Otherwise the leadership risks a
- split in the unity that has brought the independence movement
- this far. As an Eritrean civil servant put it, "We have our
- independence. That's good. Now, where are the jobs?"
- </p>
- <p> Despite such worries, the mood in the provincial capital
- of Asmara, which was retaken by the front in May, is euphoric.
- Colored lights and miniature blue, green and red E.P.L.F. flags
- decorate National Avenue, the main thoroughfare. Streets are
- filled at all hours with people strolling about, many of them
- fighters promenading hand in hand with loved ones they have not
- seen in many years. The Italian-style cafes are busy late into
- the night. "Before, we lived like prisoners here," says Yohannes
- Ande, owner of a small convenience store. "You couldn't say the
- word Eritrea. You couldn't walk on the sidewalks because of the
- sandbag bunkers the army put up on almost every corner. It was
- a dark time. Now it's going to be good."
- </p>
- <p> That sentiment is not nearly as evident in the port city
- of Massawa, which was bombed repeatedly by Mengistu's forces.
- Few buildings remain whole. Children play in the rubble with
- toys made from tank parts while abandoned Kalashnikovs rust in
- the hot, humid air. "What are we free from?" complains Tirhas,
- 20, a teacher who would not give her full name.
- </p>
- <p> Already civilian workers are grumbling about Issaias'
- decision to keep his 95,000-strong army intact to work in the
- fields and factories and on reconstruction projects. "Great,"
- says an Eritrean bureaucrat. "The volunteer army goes in, and
- the salaried civilians go out."
- </p>
- <p> Eritrea's relations with the outside world are equally
- unsteady. The province is almost completely closed off; no
- commercial flights arrive or leave. The only telephone, telex
- and radio communications possible are those that are routed
- through the front. The group blames the cutoffs on technical
- problems, but as time passes and no improvements are made, fewer
- Ethiopians believe that. Instead, the isolation appears to be
- part of a deliberate effort to assert Eritrea's independence.
- </p>
- <p> That impression is reinforced by the front's refusal to
- allow foreign diplomats based in Addis Ababa to visit the
- province. All international aid agencies with representatives
- in Asmara have been told to sit tight while their contracts are
- renegotiated; their employees are not permitted to travel or to
- communicate with the outside world. Two weeks ago, without
- explanation, the front threw out the team from the International
- Committee of the Red Cross. "There is the feeling," said one aid
- worker, "that anyone who worked with Mengistu's government is
- the enemy."
- </p>
- <p> Although the E.P.L.F. has promised to allow the rest of
- Ethiopia free access to the Eritrean port of Assab, which
- normally handles 70% of Ethiopia's trade, about the only thing
- now moving through it is food. A Shell Oil installation, which
- is under the front's control, is sending only 10% of the usual
- fuel supply to the rest of Ethiopia. Says a Western businessman
- at the port: "There is the definite feeling of a squeeze play
- here." Wary of the Eritreans, Ethiopian producers of coffee, the
- country's biggest export, are not sending their goods to Assab.
- </p>
- <p> For now, the dependence is mutual. Upon assuming control,
- Issaias was shocked to discover that the money he needed to pay
- government workers was tied up in Addis Ababa banks; he is
- currently negotiating to release it. The Eritreans depend on the
- international community even more. "We need a massive aid
- transfusion," says Girma Asmeron, chief of protocol for the
- front. "If we don't get it, frankly, we're in trouble."
- </p>
- <p> Of course, Eritrea's new relationship with Addis Ababa and
- the rest of the world may need some time to mature. Despite the
- tensions between their two camps, Issaias still speaks by phone
- every day to his old friend Meles Zenawi, leader of the reb el
- group that took control of Addis Ababa and now head of
- Ethiopia's provisional government. If a new multiparty
- transitional government--which was agreed upon last week--approves, ties between Eritrea and the rest of the country will
- be defined under an accord that calls for a mutual defense
- agreement and joint consultative committees on issues of
- security, economic affairs and the movement of people, goods and
- services.
- </p>
- <p> The danger is that one side or the other will renege on
- the delicate understanding that has been reached. The Eritreans
- could simply declare independence without a plebiscite. Issaias
- says he has received many petitions from his people to do so.
- "We are free and we are independent," says Tekie Beyene, acting
- head of the Eritrean Relief Association. "We don't need a
- referendum to tell us that."
- </p>
- <p> After three decades of civil war, Ethiopians are not eager
- to take up arms again, but many consider it an option for the
- future. "We don't need more war just now, but perhaps in five
- years we will go get Eritrea back," says a woman in Addis Ababa
- who has already lost one son in the civil war. That ordinary
- people are talking about sending their children off to war so
- soon after the killing has stopped is a measure of how
- precarious the situation remains.
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-